Loading Loading
Just for optimization

Politics.comforum

freecreditcheck.com |  creditreports.com |  whois.domaintools.com |  bookclub.com

Should the father have a say-so in whether he wants the child aborted or not?

From Blog: Eww...designer babies(WTF)

Should the father have a say-so in whether he wants the child aborted or not?

 

KristiAnn (Democratic) - Member Since: May 6th, 2009 - Debate started 6 months ago

whether youre for or against abortion, do you think the man should be able to say no when it comes to terminating a pregnancy? im a democrat but not completely sure where i stand on this topic. alot of democrats love sopporting a womens right to choose...what about a mans? pro choice seems to always be no choice for someone else...whether the father or the child.

Sorry

or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

51 Posts New Post

Sorry

or Register to reply.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

MrsPresident (Democratic) - 5 months ago

I say if the man doesn't want the abortion but the woman does then if he's going to make a stink about it he needs to be ready, willing, and able to fully take care of the child (w/o the mother), he needs to pay all of her medical bills, he needs to pay her the equivalent of her salary when she is recovering from having the baby, same if she has to go on bed rest or anything, and he needs to pay for anything and everything that needs to be fixed on her body if it's ruined from having a child she didn't want (meaning weight loss plans, gym memberships, plastic surgery, lipo, etc.)

If a man is willing to do all of this then yes he should have a say so. But only after documents and promissory notes are signed and lawyers are obtained.

Sorry

or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

reagan (Republican) - 5 months ago

Of course he does - I am tired of all these selfish women out there - if they don't want their baby, they kill it - and they don't ask the dad - they just go ahead and kill the baby - "It is the ultimate poverty that a child must die so that you may live as you wish" - Mother Theresa - and wiser words were never spoken.

Sorry

or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

KristiAnn (Democratic) - 5 months ago

Response to reagan
Of course he does - I am tired of all these selfish women out there - if they don't want their baby, … Show full post

so if neither one of the parents want the child, then should it be aborted

Sorry

or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

reagan (Republican) - 5 months ago

Response to KristiAnn
so if neither one of the parents want the child, then should it be aborted

by aborted, you mean killed - what ever happened to adoption?

Sorry

or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

MrsPresident (Democratic) - 5 months ago

Response to reagan
by aborted, you mean killed - what ever happened to adoption?

If you have noticed the trends in adoption only White and Asian babies are the ones who get adopted, Black and Spanish babies are usually left in foster homes until they have so many problems that no one wants them. Then they grow up to be bitter hateful adults who either use that hatred to motivate them or it destroys them, most of the time it's the latter. Since abortion is so wrong in your eyes please start adopting all those unwanted children out there and give them a loving home. Oh and please make sure you don't try to sell them on craigslist when they turn 5.

Sorry

or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

peabody (Independent) - 5 months ago

Response to MrsPresident
If you have noticed the trends in adoption only White and Asian babies are the ones who get adopted, … Show full post

To use trends as an excuse for denying a father the choice to not murder his child is really lame.
Trends are only statistics to show what people want seen. And trends in your area aren't reality for other places. There are plenty of white and spanish babies who don't get adopted. ANd there are a lot of black children who are adopted.

Sorry

or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

MrsPresident (Democratic) - 5 months ago

Response to peabody
To use trends as an excuse for denying a father the choice to not murder his child is really lame. … Show full post

Did you not read the first post I posted on this forum? Did I not say that if the father was willing to do everything 100% on his own then he should have a say?

I'm sick and tired of seeing girls and women running around with babies that they weren't prepared for because the father said he'd be there and then he disappears. No responsibility, no remorse, no nothing, just false promises and then leaving. What choice is his lies giving her and the child? None! When a man steps up and says hey I want this child and I will do everything that is needed you don't have to be around then that's one thing, as far as anything else? No I think they should sit back and shut up cause they really weren't planning on being there anyway, they just said what sounded good and responsible at the time.

Sorry

or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

peabody (Independent) - 5 months ago

Response to MrsPresident
Did you not read the first post I posted on this forum? Did I not say that if the father was willing … Show full post

When a woman doesn't have the choice to spread her legs, it's called rape.
The unborn child is every bit as much the father's as the mother's. Why should he have to do everything 100% on his own, as you decree?
Girls and women will continue to run around with babies they're not prepared to have as long pregnancy, babies and unmarried sex are glamorized.

Sorry

or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

MrsPresident (Democratic) - 5 months ago

Response to peabody
When a woman doesn't have the choice to spread her legs, it's called rape. The unborn child is ev … Show full post

If he want's the child and she doesn't then he should be 100% responsible, same thing goes the other way around. I'm not an advocate of unfair treatment. I have no idea where you live but pregnancy and babies are not glamorized and never were. Unmarried sex is a common place all across the world, just because someone gets married that does not mean they are willing or want to have babies. Most of the married people I know have been married since HS (10 years) and still do not want children and never want them. So how does that one work out? I also know a few people who have divorced cause the husband said no kids and the wife tricked him into it. Yet again how does that one work out?

Sorry

or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

hepsy 5 months ago

Response to MrsPresident
If he want's the child and she doesn't then he should be 100% responsible, same thing goes the other … Show full post

It doesn't work into it at all when the value of life is reduced to zero.

Sorry

or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

hepsy 5 months ago

Response to MrsPresident
If he want's the child and she doesn't then he should be 100% responsible, same thing goes the other … Show full post

Too big a shock?

Sorry

or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

peabody (Independent) - 5 months ago

Response to MrsPresident
If he want's the child and she doesn't then he should be 100% responsible, same thing goes the other … Show full post

Marriage is the best environment for a child, with a mother and a father in a committed relationship.
HS girls want babies until they find out what it's like to have to take care of them all the time. HS girls and boys have their hormones in high gear and think sex is glamorous, just like the movies they watch.
But none of this has anything to do with fathers having a say in their babies not being aborted.

Sorry

or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

I guess myabe like Mrs Pres says if he agree to all those things. However I think any woman would be foolish to count on legal agreement insuring her security, let alone the security of a child. What I mean is she is still the one that has to give birth. It's not like if he renegs she can take him to court, be made whole, and start all over. No I do not think the man should have say. Not an equal one. Consideration yes.

Sorry

or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

Pierre Sarkozy (Green) - 5 months ago

Response to peabody
Marriage is the best environment for a child, with a mother and a father in a committed relationship … Show full post

How do you know marriage is the best environment for a child?

Sorry

or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

MrsPresident (Democratic) - 5 months ago

Response to amnestymyazz
I guess myabe like Mrs Pres says if he agree to all those things. However I think any woman would b … Show full post

Hmmm I kinda like what you said, maybe I can't be mad at you for the whole DADT debate anymore. <sigh> My new enemy gone up in smoke..... :)

Sorry

or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

MrsPresident (Democratic) - 5 months ago

Response to peabody
Marriage is the best environment for a child, with a mother and a father in a committed relationship … Show full post

Marriage is not always the best environment for a child, two people committed to loving one another and raising that child into adulthood is the best environment. The second best is a responsible adult who is committed to the child in all aspects of life.

Sorry

or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

hepsy 5 months ago

Response to amnestymyazz
I guess myabe like Mrs Pres says if he agree to all those things. However I think any woman would b … Show full post

Can't count on a father to support his child, so abort the baby?
If a father has intentions to support and/or rear the child, and the mother wants to abort, the mother wins because a child is growing inside her body? Not all women are wimps when it comes to nurturing.
If a father, in whatever type of commitment, reneges on his deal with mother/child, what do you propose to do with the child?

Sorry

or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

Response to hepsy
Can't count on a father to support his child, so abort the baby? If a father has intentions to sup … Show full post

The fact of the matter is men do not give birth. The mother is the one that is 100% responsible for giving birth to the child. Our society assigns responsibility to the father when it comes to the upbringing and care of the child once it is born. I know I do not need to quote statistics to show how often that responsibility is ignored. The question was not should abortion be legal. The question is should a father have equal say regarding the decision to abort. When men start carrying babies in the womb, men get to have equal input. Until then it is a womans decision. Period.

Sorry

or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

Response to hepsy
Can't count on a father to support his child, so abort the baby? If a father has intentions to sup … Show full post

If a father, in whatever type of commitment, reneges on his deal with mother/child, what do you propose to do with the child?
That's kind of my point. Binding legal agreement does not take care of the child. Compliance with the agreement does. What happens to a child when the mother doesn't want it and the father changes his mind? Again the question posed is should the father have equal say in the decision to abort. How about if the child poses a health risk to the mother during childbirth and she wishes to abort? Why should the wish of the father trump the wishes of the person solely responsible for giving birth? In answer to your final question I say that scenario should never exist since the decision to give birth is solely that of the mother.

Sorry

or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

hepsy 5 months ago

Response to amnestymyazz
The fact of the matter is men do not give birth. The mother is the one that is 100% responsible for … Show full post

You didn t see the pregnant dude? : )
A mother has sole responsibility for an unborn child only when the father is a male who doesn't know, or doesn't care, that life extends beyond himself, and he lacks the fortitude to be a man beyond gender. A man equipped with as much upstairs as downstairs won't need suggestion of responsibility. It strikes me that our narcissistic society, with a focus on devaluing moral standards in exchange for how something feels, does much to distract a man from what he would naturally do: ensure the life of his line.

The burden of pregnancy makes it easy to see a mother's responsibility to an unborn child. It's a bit more challenging to think outside the box, so to speak, to comprehend a father's role in his offspring's life. I fail to see how pregnancy trumps paternity as the measure to determine who gets a say in life and death.

Sorry

or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

Response to hepsy
You didn t see the pregnant dude? : ) A mother has sole responsibility for an unborn child only wh … Show full post

This is, IMHO, one of theose rare instances in life where things are decidely one-sided. What if things were the other way around? What if he wanted the abortion and she did not?

Sorry

or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

hepsy 5 months ago

Response to amnestymyazz
If a father, in whatever type of commitment, reneges on his deal with mother/child, what do you prop … Show full post

What's done with the child now, when the father walks out on a young child?
The father often contributes financially to the child's support until he's 18.

The person most affected in any abortion is the unborn child. But, this isn't about abortion, just who has a say in an abortion. I'd say give the baby the choice rather than either parent, as the parents already made theirs.

The question of who has a say in abortion is really inappropriate as the question of when life begins, and when life ends, is not medically distinguished. The reality of that is lost in the social, emotional Politically Correct debate. Our society is largely inured to the plight of an unborn human in favor of emotional and financial convenience.

It is politicking that obfuscates the value of the life of an unborn baby, regardless of what question about it is posed. Ours is an increasingly narcissistic society, with a focus on how we feel about things, and immature decisions based from personal experience. The decision to procreate is usually mutual. The birthing process is biological. There will probably always be young (and older) women pregnant before they've gained the emotional maturity to mother and young (and older) men adept in the act of procreation but lack the manhood to, well, be a real man.

IMHO, many questions surrounding abortion are inappropriately in the political arena, and those questions become moot when the topic returns to: Is abortion the premeditated taking of human life? If so, address that. If there's a medical presentation, politics has no business there, either. But, I am not one to embrace Political Correctness, which is what abortion is. Abortion is the politicization of human life.

Sorry

or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

hepsy 5 months ago

Response to amnestymyazz
This is, IMHO, one of theose rare instances in life where things are decidely one-sided. What if th … Show full post

IMHO, I d like to see the entire issue out of the political arena.
Would the question then be one of, what if the father didn't want to be a father? Adoption. Many non-biological fathers do better at fathering than biological fathers.
We all make mistakes, we all do things without thinking them through before acting. Probably very few lives don't have scars of some sort. It's what we choose to do when we recognize where we are in life, and where we want to go, that is of substance. Personally, I admire more the person who has made mistakes and tough decisions to get through them, than the one who has kept his life safe.

Sorry

or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

Response to hepsy
IMHO, I d like to see the entire issue out of the political arena. Would the question then be one … Show full post

There is another semantic involved here. I know this means the consideration (vote) of the child is being forgotten here. If you give the father 'equal' consideration, you are in fact making him the deciding authority. I mean if he votes to have the child, the mothers wishes are moot. If he defers to abortion, you then are asking the mother simply if she concurs or not. I mean he doesn't have to give birth. If he says abort, he puts the whole thing on the mother. If he says to keep the child, she still is the one that has to go through the whole process, not him. There is also the legal aspect. A lawyer could argue, if the law stated equal consideration, that a father voting to abort the child is then free of financial obligation should the mother choose to keep the child.

Sorry

or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

Jeremy86 (Democratic) - 5 months ago

Aren't we forgetting one key component of this debate: the landmark case of Schwarzenegger v. Thompson?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Junior_(film)

I do suggest that we might find the answer to this whole debate in that case!

Sorry

or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!

1 - 25 / 50
Previous 1 2 Next
51 Posts New Post