Loading
wayway2tall 8 months agoWell Israellis see it as they're people endured the pyramids, living in the middle east for 3000 years, the holocaust, and woody allen why should they have to explain themselves to you. And that's a very difficult point to argue. But ever since the Israellis developed nuclear weapons they've thought they were the big swinging d***s of the middle east (which I think is ironic) They need to chill out. But at this point the palestinians are giving them every excuse to say that they're fighting for their lives. justsimpleinfo (Independent) - 8 months agonothing wrong with trashing israel, in my opinion... I have nothing bad to say about them. I guess I am wondering if its your opinion why anybody would take it seriously unless your opinion included something directing other people to harm israel. AM365 (Independent) - 7 months agoWhy do you feel the need to trash Israel? voiceofreason 3 months ago
Response to AM365
Why do you feel the need to trash Israel? Let's take a look at some of their accomplishments. … Show full post I was just about to point a few of these out but dang looks like you covered a lot about Israel... the French are annoying... why not start a French bashing post I think you will get more support there.. and I have French blood I will even join the bashing. Hard to listen to anything the French have to complain about... Political 1 month agoAccomplishments of the Israelis aren't enough to make up for the negative actions of the Israeli government. I don't think that the ADL should limit free speech if a persons says something bad about Israel. Israelis didn't have to endure the holocaust. Israel was established after the holocaust and holocaust survivors who moved there didn't live their before the holocaust. Israelis didn't live there for 3000 years either. Israel wasn't a country before 1948 and when it there was the Kingdom of Israel it was Israelites who were a different people. I have nothing against Israelis but moderators shouldn't prohibit criticism of the Israeli government. Its a sad day when an American can badmouth the American government but not the Israeli government. guitar102 (Democratic) - 2 weeks ago
Response to wayway2tall
Well Israellis see it as they're people endured the pyramids, living in the middle east for 3000 yea … Show full post Wayway2tall, I'm going to go out on the limb and ASSUME you know how to read! I was asking a question not stating an opinion and I included the reasons for my question! Before your Pavlovic seizure to fulminate the history of the Jews etc. you should have stopped and reread what I wrote which is 'Is it OK to criticize Israel on this site because other sites would not even allow discussions of this for fear that someone would kneejerk 'antisemitism' to the ADL after which the ADL would rain hell down upon the site owners if not have the site shut down completely. At many opinion sites the moderators have expressed genuine anxiety about this happening. guitar102 (Democratic) - 2 weeks ago
Response to justsimpleinfo
nothing wrong with trashing israel, in my opinion... I have nothing bad to say about them. I guess … Show full post It's just that certain sites don't what the ADL brought down upon their heads for 'promoting antisemitism' when the members were merely criticizing Israel. And the ADL does consider the criticism of Israel to be antisemitism, hate speech, etc. Do they care about the 1st amendment? Of course not! guitar102 (Democratic) - 2 weeks ago
Response to AM365
Why do you feel the need to trash Israel? Let's take a look at some of their accomplishments. … Show full post Actually your post, although well researched, has nothing to do with my original post which was not a criticism of Israel (that I will get to later) but a question to the members here whether or not it was OK to criticize Israel as far too many opinion sites are too afraid to even have the issue brought up! They are afraid of someone complaining about the criticism to the Anti Defamation League who does regard criticisms of Israel to be hate speech and antisemitism. ksioal 4 days agoBeautiful "Xinhua Gate" scandal 1 - 9 / 9
|
guitar102 (Democratic) - Member Since: Aug 8th, 2009 - Debate started 8 months ago
I'm only asking because I've seen this happen on so many other opinions sites! You say something that hits really close to home and some Israel firster threatens to call the ADL against the site (they can have them shut down!) & the moderators say - you can express any opinion you want but just not about Israel. This happens a lot more than some people may want to believe!
Sorry
Login or Register to add your comment.
It will take only a few seconds, we promise!